{
  "schema": "dense-kv-oracle-ablation-report.v1",
  "pairs": 10,
  "unique_questions": 128,
  "examples_per_task": {
    "arc_challenge": 32,
    "medqa": 32,
    "mmlu_redux": 32,
    "openbookqa": 32
  },
  "arm_mean_accuracy_pct": {
    "native": 72.109375,
    "mapped": 43.671875,
    "mapped_k_native_v": 56.015625,
    "native_k_mapped_v": 49.140625
  },
  "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 6.875000000000001,
  "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
    3.9843749999999996,
    9.765625000000002
  ],
  "values_worse_directions": 7,
  "keys_worse_directions": 3,
  "ties": 0,
  "inference_scope": "Fixed ten pilot adapters; question uncertainty, not model/training-seed uncertainty.",
  "ci_method": "10,000 paired task-stratified question bootstrap draws; shared IDs clustered across directions.",
  "replay": {
    "native": {
      "prediction_mismatches": 0,
      "max_absolute_logprob_delta": 0.0
    },
    "mapped": {
      "prediction_mismatches": 0,
      "max_absolute_logprob_delta": 0.0
    }
  },
  "directions": [
    {
      "source": "H0.6",
      "target": "H1.7",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 68.75,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 44.53125,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 41.40625,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 61.71875,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 27.34375,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 7.03125,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 17.1875,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": -3.125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": -20.3125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        -30.46875,
        -10.15625
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.894356319893331,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 3.2172700220825936,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.4746817820427047,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.35643459593009,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.0566243077269744,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.3508302510512595,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.7460886789383858
    },
    {
      "source": "H1.7",
      "target": "H0.6",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 46.875,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 58.59375,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 55.46875,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 41.40625,
      "key_only_drop_pp": -8.59375,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 5.46875,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": -17.1875,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": -3.125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 14.0625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        4.6875,
        23.4375
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.3015692307714515,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.1807561973895448,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.5873673148504972,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.155059342623784,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.591445539287573,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.3224636833475094,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.24895158226085
    },
    {
      "source": "H1.7",
      "target": "H4",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 71.09375,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 21.875,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 41.40625,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 28.125,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 29.6875,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 42.96875,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 6.25,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 19.53125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 13.28125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        4.6875,
        22.65625
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 4.077859043089449,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.7261232803344508,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 2.824793669556044,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.5823522013184377,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 4.578779216528545,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.128155363931332,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.2566776892011884
    },
    {
      "source": "H4",
      "target": "H1.7",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 68.75,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 21.875,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 23.4375,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 21.875,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 45.3125,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 46.875,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 0.0,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 1.5625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 1.5625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        -1.5625,
        4.6875
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 2.895553440381998,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 4.68098287619965,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 3.610585892622359,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.35643459593009,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.684526729662352,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 4.346899518315642,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.5921919134966847
    },
    {
      "source": "H4",
      "target": "H8",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 75.0,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 71.875,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 70.3125,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 73.4375,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 4.6875,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 1.5625,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 1.5625,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": -1.5625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": -3.125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        -10.9375,
        4.6875
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.3131328262740343,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.1931195345076764,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.19395017188572855,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.5128318825716676,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.4779368999933562,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.6267026431372402,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.2056048789618043
    },
    {
      "source": "H8",
      "target": "H4",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 71.09375,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 68.75,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 71.875,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 71.09375,
      "key_only_drop_pp": -0.78125,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 0.0,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 2.34375,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 3.125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 0.78125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        -7.03125,
        8.59375
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 2.0155574224083237,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.656654851315485,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.45945937369887957,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 3.5823522013184377,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.9680893245408864,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.7358977042679895,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.7979806863335153
    },
    {
      "source": "H8",
      "target": "H14",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 78.90625,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 45.3125,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 65.625,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 46.875,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 13.28125,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 32.03125,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 1.5625,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 20.3125,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 18.75,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        7.03125,
        30.46875
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.1662332894211194,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.6549086849464113,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.0386858167464292,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.3393513063114555,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.2595930642187718,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.2611346046607652,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.2431165496123597
    },
    {
      "source": "H14",
      "target": "H8",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 75.0,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 42.1875,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 64.0625,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 41.40625,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 10.9375,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 33.59375,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": -0.78125,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 21.875,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 22.65625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        12.5,
        32.8125
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.2950011993137642,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.679768952639797,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.702679479846574,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.5128318825716676,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.3825241437234763,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.1603463362616981,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.8774049694304347
    },
    {
      "source": "H14",
      "target": "H32",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 86.71875,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 40.625,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 69.53125,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 75.0,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 17.1875,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 11.71875,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 34.375,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 28.90625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": -5.46875,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        -13.28125,
        3.125
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.2190388935888052,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.6132329823961882,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 0.5535787490386708,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 0.6433423837841077,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.3184984002364661,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 0.8762145142376095,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 0.7322533149513681
    },
    {
      "source": "H32",
      "target": "H14",
      "native_accuracy_pct": 78.90625,
      "mapped_accuracy_pct": 21.09375,
      "mapped_k_native_v_accuracy_pct": 57.03125,
      "native_k_mapped_v_accuracy_pct": 30.46875,
      "key_only_drop_pp": 21.875,
      "value_only_drop_pp": 48.4375,
      "key_repair_gain_pp": 9.375,
      "value_repair_gain_pp": 35.9375,
      "value_minus_key_harm_pp": 26.5625,
      "value_minus_key_harm_ci95": [
        15.625,
        37.5
      ],
      "native_mean_choice_kl": 0.0,
      "mapped_mean_choice_kl": 1.6458103176133247,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.3379076802269774,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_choice_kl": 1.51716346096547,
      "native_mean_gold_choice_nll": 2.3393513063114555,
      "mapped_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.6643071802585419,
      "mapped_k_native_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.6734277660177406,
      "native_k_mapped_v_mean_gold_choice_nll": 1.6230035996742675
    }
  ],
  "provenance": {
    "experiment_artifact": "results/dense-kv-ablation-20261009/report/summary.json",
    "sha256": "139e644127c92aad7e678c38400f7a2973d61c3a8ee10276aac61df2ca08224b",
    "experiment_date": "2026-10-09"
  },
  "limits": [
    "Native components require receiver prefill and are diagnostic oracles, not deployable speedups.",
    "These are fixed short-budget dense pilot adapters, not direct HeteroFold or KV-Lingo ablations.",
    "The 128 questions are shared across directions; 5120 condition records are not independent questions.",
    "No new value-focused training has been tested."
  ]
}
